Creamy Polenta Roasted Mushrooms

There's something about the smell of polenta bubbling on the stove that makes even a Tuesday night feel special. I discovered this dish during a particularly chilly autumn when I needed something that felt both simple and luxurious, and polenta delivered exactly that. The creamy base comes together quickly, leaving you free to focus on the mushrooms, which somehow transform into something almost meaty and deeply satisfying. It's the kind of meal that tastes like you've been cooking for hours, but you haven't.

I made this for friends on a rainy evening, and watching them dig into the creamy polenta base with genuine enthusiasm reminded me why I love cooking. Someone asked if it was difficult, and I got to say no, and mean it. That moment, seeing comfort on their faces, is when I knew this recipe had staying power in my regular rotation.

Ingredients

• Coarse cornmeal (polenta), 1 cup: The foundation of everything—look for polenta labeled coarse or cornmeal, not fine cornflour, or you'll end up with mush instead of velvety texture.
• Water and whole milk, 4 cups and 1 cup: The combination of water and milk strikes the balance between richness and not feeling heavy; milk alone would overwhelm the polenta flavor.
• Unsalted butter, 3 tablespoons: Stir this in at the end and watch the polenta transform into something almost luxurious—it's the secret finish.
• Grated Parmesan cheese, 1/2 cup: Freshly grated tastes infinitely better than pre-grated, and you'll taste the difference in every spoonful.
• Kosher salt and black pepper, 1 tsp and to taste: Salt goes into the cooking liquid, and pepper finishes the bowl—don't skip seasoning either stage.
• Mixed mushrooms, 1 pound: Use whatever you find—cremini, shiitake, oyster, even button mushrooms will caramelize beautifully if you give them time and heat.
• Olive oil, 2 tablespoons: Just enough to coat the mushrooms and help them brown; more would make them greasy instead of golden.
• Garlic and fresh thyme: These two bring the savory depth that makes people ask what spice you used—it's just good technique, not a secret ingredient.
• Fresh parsley for garnish: A small handful of green at the end brightens the whole plate and reminds you you're eating something alive and fresh.

Instructions

Start the mushrooms first:

Preheat your oven to 425°F and toss your sliced mushrooms with olive oil, minced garlic, thyme, salt, and pepper on a baking sheet. Spread them in a single layer so they actually touch the hot pan and roast for 20 to 25 minutes, stirring once halfway through, until they're golden and smell incredible.

Build the polenta base:

While mushrooms are roasting, bring water and milk to a boil in a large saucepan and add salt. This is important—boil it first so the cornmeal doesn't clump up on you.

Add the cornmeal slowly:

Reduce heat to low and whisk the cornmeal in gradually, keeping the mixture moving so no lumps form. You're essentially cooking a thick pudding here, and patience prevents disappointment.

Stir until creamy:

Keep stirring frequently for 20 to 25 minutes until the polenta is thick and creamy and pulls away slightly from the sides of the pan. It should look glossy and feel silky, not grainy, when you taste a tiny spoonful.

Finish with richness:

Remove from heat and stir in butter, Parmesan, and fresh ground black pepper. This final seasoning is where the magic happens—taste it and adjust until it feels luxurious.

Bring it together:

Spoon warm polenta into bowls and top generously with roasted mushrooms, the pan juices, fresh parsley, and extra Parmesan if you're feeling generous.

Pin Recipe

The first time someone asked for seconds, I realized this dish had crossed over from weeknight dinner to something people actually crave. That's when polenta stopped being just a side dish in my mind and became the whole story.

The Magic of Polenta

Polenta has this incredible ability to feel both humble and elegant depending on how you treat it. The corn flavor is subtle, almost sweet, which is why it pairs so beautifully with earthy mushrooms and umami-rich cheese. When you taste polenta made properly, you understand why people have been making it for centuries—it's satisfying without being heavy, and it stretches ingredients without ever feeling cheap. The butter and Parmesan at the end transform it completely, turning something simple into something memorable.

Roasting Mushrooms Like You Mean It

The key to mushrooms that taste like something is dry heat and patience. When you roast them hard enough to brown, they concentrate their flavors instead of steaming into mush. I learned this the hard way by cooking them too gently and wondering why they tasted bland. Now I push the heat high and let them sit undisturbed for that first stretch, giving them time to develop color. The garlic and thyme steep into the oil and mushroom juices, creating something that tastes far more complex than the sum of its parts.

Variations and Flexibility

One of the reasons I keep making this dish is how easily it bends to what you have or what you're craving. On nights when I want extra richness, I drizzle the finished bowl with truffle oil and watch people's faces light up. For guests with dietary preferences, swapping butter and Parmesan for plant-based alternatives works beautifully, and nutritional yeast adds a cheesy depth that feels indulgent. You can also pile roasted vegetables alongside—grilled asparagus or charred tomatoes echo the roasted mushroom theme without needing much extra work.

• Serve alongside a crisp green salad to balance the richness with something bright and acidic.
• Top with a fried egg or crispy sage leaves if you want to push it toward breakfast or brunch instead.
• Make it vegan by using plant-based butter and nutritional yeast, and nobody will feel like they're missing anything.

Pin Recipe

This is the kind of recipe that makes regular cooking feel rewarding—straightforward enough to make on a weeknight, but impressive enough to serve when it matters. I hope it becomes as much of a comfort to you as it's become to me.

Recipe FAQs

→ What type of mushrooms work best for this dish?

Mixed mushrooms like cremini, shiitake, and oyster are ideal as they offer a variety of textures and earthy flavors that complement the creamy polenta.

→ How do I achieve a creamy polenta texture?

Slowly whisking cornmeal into boiling water and milk and stirring frequently while cooking on low heat helps develop a smooth, velvety consistency.

→ Can I substitute Parmesan cheese in this dish?

Yes, for a vegan option, nutritional yeast can be used as a substitute to provide a cheesy flavor without dairy.

→ What herbs enhance the flavor of the roasted mushrooms?

Fresh or dried thyme adds a fragrant, earthy note that pairs beautifully with garlic and the natural mushroom flavor.

→ Is this dish suitable for gluten-free diets?

Yes, using certified gluten-free cornmeal and ensuring other ingredients are gluten-free keeps the dish compliant for gluten-sensitive diets.